Insurance agents in Columbia, IL

20 insurance agents listed in Columbia, Illinois. 18 with a phone number and 18 with a website.

Columbia accounts for 0.2% of the insurance agents listed in Illinois.

Quick answer

Columbia, IL has 20 insurance agents listed on USA Business Search. 18 list a phone number and 18 list a website. The most listings are in ZIP codes 62236.

Updated October 2026

R.w. Hettenhausen Insurors, Inc.

1013 N Main St, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 281-4800 Website

Accent Title

399 Veterans Pkwy, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 281-2040 Website

Cole Proffer: Primerica - Financial Services

207 N Main St Ste 214, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 719-6007 Website

Craig Hansen: Primerica - Financial Services

207 N MAIN St Ste 214, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 719-9343 Website

Donna Konarcik with Unterseh-Schreder Insurance Agency

1013 N Main St, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 281-1616 Website

Farmers Insurance - Danny Schwartz

278 Southwoods Ctr, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 235-2091 Website

Mack Risk Management

103 McCrosky Professional Park, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 281-8887 Website

Shelter Insurance

1180 Admiral Weinel Blvd, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 719-2516 Website

Sippel Insurance Agency

212 W Locust St, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 281-9200 Website

Taake Insurance Agency LTD

300 Wedgewood Sq, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 281-7656 Website

The Health Insurance Guy

204 S Main St, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (314) 602-4055 Website

Nolkemper Insurance Agency

808 N Main St, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 539-6100 Website

Mitch Essert - State Farm Insurance Agent

400 Columbia Ctr, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 281-7181 Website

Columbia Insurance Group

960 Columbia Centre Dr, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 470-6008 Website

Allstate Insurance: Bret Boyd

1260 Columbia Centre, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 234-1234 Website

Shelter Insurance - Timothy Stanberry

207 N Main St Ste 110a, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 719-2516 Website

Bruce Doyle - State Farm Insurance Agent

100 Veterans Pkwy, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 281-2301

Trevor Halloran - State Farm Insurance Agent

100 Veterans Pkwy, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Call (618) 281-2301

State Farm

400 Columbia Ctr, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Website

State Farm

100 Veterans Parkway, Columbia, IL 62236 · Claim or fix

Website

How to choose an insurance agency in Columbia

Compare at least three quotes with the same coverage limits.
Ask which carriers they represent.
Ask how claims are handled and who you call when something happens.

Check the business: confirm a company's registration with the state in our Illinois business lookup guide, and licensed trades in the contractor license lookup guide.

Common questions

How many insurance agents are listed in Columbia, Illinois?

USA Business Search shows 20 insurance agents in Columbia. 18 list a phone number and 18 list a website.

Which ZIP codes do these listings cover?

They include ZIP codes 62236.

How do I choose an insurance agency in Columbia?

Compare at least three quotes with the same coverage limits. Ask which carriers they represent. Ask how claims are handled and who you call when something happens. Check the license or registration through the Illinois business lookup guide.

How do I add or fix a listing?

Listings are free. Use Add your business, or the Claim or fix link on any listing.

More finance & insurance in Columbia

Banks & credit unions in Columbia

All insurance agents in Illinois Insurance agents nationwide

Own one of these businesses? Claim your free listing or see what an optimized listing adds.