Thrift & consignment in Indiana

2,077 thrift & consignment listed across 338 cities in Indiana.

Quick answer

USA Business Search lists 2,077 thrift & consignment in Indiana. The most are in Indianapolis (195), Fort Wayne (78), Evansville (67).

Updated November 2026

Thrift & consignment by city

Indianapolis (195)Fort Wayne (78)Evansville (67)Elkhart (43)Lafayette (40)Kokomo (32)Muncie (31)Bloomington (30)South Bend (27)Terre Haute (27)Columbus (27)Crown Point (26)Michigan City (26)Goshen (25)Noblesville (23)Mishawaka (22)Franklin (22)Gary (21)Madison (21)Richmond (20)Anderson (19)Marion (18)Clarksville (18)Valparaiso (17)Shelbyville (17)Greenwood (16)Warsaw (16)Crawfordsville (16)Peru (16)Corydon (16)Greenfield (15)Plymouth (15)New Albany (14)Hammond (14)Jeffersonville (13)La Porte (13)New Castle (13)Shipshewana (13)Rockville (13)Cambridge City (13)Huntington (12)Chesterton (12)Wabash (12)Merrillville (11)Seymour (11)Bedford (11)Frankfort (11)Boonville (11)Avon (10)Vincennes (10)Angola (10)Kendallville (10)Nashville (10)Carmel (9)Plainfield (9)Highland (9)Auburn (9)Connersville (9)Rochester (9)Syracuse (9)Knightstown (9)Fishers (8)Brownsburg (8)Newburgh (8)Jasper (8)Martinsville (8)Lawrenceburg (8)Bluffton (8)Monticello (8)North Vernon (8)Pendleton (8)Lowell (8)Beech Grove (8)Osceola (8)Pierceton (8)Centerville (8)Westfield (7)Portage (7)Lebanon (7)Greensburg (7)Mooresville (7)Hobart (7)Scottsburg (7)Brazil (7)Salem (7)Princeton (7)Aurora (7)Cedar Lake (7)North Manchester (7)New Harmony (7)Schererville (6)Zionsville (6)Logansport (6)Granger (6)Washington (6)Decatur (6)Danville (6)Middlebury (6)Portland (6)Mitchell (6)Grabill (6)Griffith (5)Batesville (5)Demotte (5)Tell City (5)Knox (5)Floyds Knobs (5)Sullivan (5)Winamac (5)Hartford City (5)Gas City (5)Attica (5)Wakarusa (5)Montgomery (5)Kirklin (5)Columbia City (4)Nappanee (4)Sellersburg (4)Rensselaer (4)Rushville (4)

Well-documented thrift & consignment in Indiana

A sample of listings with a street address, phone number and website, one per city.

Cash America Pawn

1910 E Stop 13 Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46227 · Claim or fix

Call (317) 881-6199 Website

Goodwill Industries - Lima Rd Store

4122 Lima Rd B6, Fort Wayne, IN 46805 · Claim or fix

Call (260) 482-5744 Website

Goldman's Pawn Shop

107 SE 4th St, Evansville, IN 47708 · Claim or fix

Call (812) 423-9631 Website

Stash Boutique Consignment

118 S Main St, Elkhart, IN 46516 · Claim or fix

Call (574) 389-7446 Website

Goodwill Store

3229 Daugherty Dr, Lafayette, IN 47909 · Claim or fix

Call (317) 524-4313 Website

Paradise Trading Post

919 E Markland Ave, Kokomo, IN 46901 · Claim or fix

Call (765) 450-5677 Website

Goodwill Store

1413 E 29th St, Muncie, IN 47302 · Claim or fix

Call (317) 524-4313 Website

Bloomington Antique Mall

311 W 7th St, Bloomington, IN 47404 · Claim or fix

Call (812) 323-7676 Website

Goodwill Industries

1906 E Ireland Rd, South Bend, IN 46614 · Claim or fix

Call (574) 231-9913 Website

Style Encore

4432 S US Hwy 41 #95, Terre Haute, IN 47802 · Claim or fix

Call (812) 814-3534 Website

Garden City Iron & Metal

5 Kenmill St, Columbus, IN 47201 · Claim or fix

Call (888) 586-5322 Website

Second Life Resale Shoppe

1800 N Main St, Crown Point, IN 46307 · Claim or fix

Call (219) 663-5266 Website

How to choose a thrift store in Indiana

Check hours and stock by phone before you make the trip.
Ask about return and exchange policies.
Ask whether they price-match or offer local delivery.

Common questions

How many thrift & consignment are listed in Indiana?

USA Business Search lists 2,077 thrift & consignment in Indiana, in 338 cities and towns.

Which Indiana cities have the most thrift & consignment?

Indianapolis (195), Fort Wayne (78), Evansville (67), Elkhart (43), Lafayette (40).

How do I verify a Indiana business?

Use the state's official business search and licensing boards, linked in our Indiana business lookup guide.

Thrift & consignment nationwide Indiana directory