Pizza in Bay Shore, NY
20 pizza listed in Bay Shore, New York. 19 with a phone number and 15 with a website.
Bay Shore accounts for 0% of the pizza listed in New York and ranks #38 among New York cities for pizza.
Sponsored
Quick answer
Bay Shore, NY has 20 pizza listed on USA Business Search. 19 list a phone number and 15 list a website. The most listings are in ZIP codes 11706.
Updated October 2026Valentinos
Amore Pizza
The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
Bruno's Pizzeria and Restaurant
Sbarro
Albert's
Bay Shore, NY - South Shore
Blaze Pizza
Elio's Pizzeria
Fredy's Pizza & Restaurant
Ginos
Jerry's
Joe's Pasta & Pizza
La Casa Pizza & Pasta
Mama Deluca Pizza
Papa John's Pizza
Pizza Hut Express
The Classic New York Pizza Joint
The Pie at Salvatore's
How to choose a pizza place in Bay Shore
- Check current hours before you go. Many places change hours seasonally.
- Call ahead for large groups, catering or dietary needs.
- Look at recent photos and reviews, not just the star rating.
Common questions
How many pizza are listed in Bay Shore, New York?
USA Business Search shows 20 pizza in Bay Shore. 19 list a phone number and 15 list a website.
Which ZIP codes do these listings cover?
They include ZIP codes 11706.
How do I choose a pizza place in Bay Shore?
Check current hours before you go. Many places change hours seasonally. Call ahead for large groups, catering or dietary needs.
How do pizza in Bay Shore compare with the rest of New York?
Bay Shore has 0% of the 6,986 pizza listed in New York, which ranks #38 among New York cities for this category.
How do I add or fix a listing?
Listings are free. Use Add your business, or the Claim or fix link on any listing.
More food & drink in Bay Shore
Pizza nearby
Own one of these businesses? Claim your free listing or see what an optimized listing adds.