Insurance agents in Brookhaven, NY

31 insurance agents listed in Brookhaven, New York. 31 with a phone number and 29 with a website.

Brookhaven accounts for 0% of the insurance agents listed in New York and ranks #50 among New York cities for insurance agents.

Quick answer

Brookhaven, NY has 31 insurance agents listed on USA Business Search. 31 list a phone number and 29 list a website. The most listings are in ZIP codes 11763, 11778, 11772.

Updated October 2026

Michele Kitterle: Allstate Insurance

625A Portion Rd, Brookhaven, NY 11779 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 567-5544 Website Map

Metro Agency Unlimited

538 NY-25A, Brookhaven, NY 11778 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 849-1101 Website Map

Michael Cirigliano

629 NY-112 #10, Brookhaven, NY 11772 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 758-7225 Website Map

Mary Rose Smith

2096 NY-112, Brookhaven, NY 11763 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 307-9010 Website Map

Ed Reilly

190 N Belle Mead Rd Ste 4, Brookhaven, NY 11733 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 941-7194 Website Map

Marlin Insurance Agency

1138 William Floyd Pkwy, Brookhaven, NY 11967 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 281-6200 Website Map

Adjuster Advocates

9 Deerfield Dr, Brookhaven, NY 11792 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 953-7005 Website Map

Allstate Insurance

2864 NY-112, Brookhaven, NY 11763 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 721-9111 Website Map

Amitrano Insurance Services

4 Norwood Ln, Brookhaven, NY 11779 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 648-7845 Map

Associated Risk Management Agency

538 NY-25A, Brookhaven, NY 11778 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 209-7475 Map

Cue Brokerage Group

180 E Main St #201, Brookhaven, NY 11772 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 475-6000 Website Map

DeVito Insurance

271-2 NY-25A, Brookhaven, NY 11766 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 509-6388 Website Map

Don Pawluk

1303 Main St, Brookhaven, NY 11777 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 393-2775 Website Map

Elena Kolesnikova

3249 Rte 112 Building 4 Suite1A, Brookhaven, NY 11763 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 721-4997 Website Map

Esquire Agency

396 William Floyd Pkwy Suite B, Brookhaven, NY 11967 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 873-3825 Website Map

Faulkner Insurance Brokerage

62 N Country Rd, Brookhaven, NY 11786 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 849-5858 Website Map

First Insure Group USA

159 NY-25A i, Brookhaven, NY 11764 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 509-1718 Website Map

Frank Raffone

4940 Nesconset Hwy, Brookhaven, NY 11776 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 928-9232 Website Map

Island Wide Insurance Agency

878 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven, NY 11967 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 395-1000 Website Map

John Fischer - State Farm Insurance Agent

271 Middle Country Rd, Brookhaven, NY 11784 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 696-9800 Website Map

Kathleen Handley

460 County Rd 111 Ste 5, Brookhaven, NY 11949 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 399-1500 Website Map

Kyra Slade Insurance Agency Inc.

128 Main St Ste C, Brookhaven, NY 11980 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 335-3945 Website Map

Matthew C Daley Insurance Agency

1010 NY-112 #200, Brookhaven, NY 11776 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 744-3350 Website Map

Melissa A Daley Insurance Agency

1010 NY-112 #200, Brookhaven, NY 11776 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 542-0101 Website Map

Pro Insurance Agency

21 Bennetts Rd Ste 202, Brookhaven, NY 11733 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 361-5005 Website Map

Randy Pelosi

1239 N Country Rd #1a, Brookhaven, NY 11790 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 751-6800 Website Map

Rhonda Cooper - UnitedHealthcare Licensed Sales Agent

107 Emily Dr, Brookhaven, NY 11720 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 805-3736 Website Map

Robert Donahue State Farm Insurance

499-77 Sunrise Hwy, Brookhaven, NY 11772 · Claim or fix

Call (718) 459-2609 Website Map

Sound Risk Management Corp.

428 NY-25A Ste 2A, Brookhaven, NY 11764 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 509-1023 Website Map

The Clausen Agency

333 NY-25A Ste 150, Brookhaven, NY 11778 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 744-1393 Website Map

Vincent & Vincent Property & Casualty Services Inc

179 Country Rd, Brookhaven, NY 11763 · Claim or fix

Call (631) 775-7916 Website Map

How to choose an insurance agency in Brookhaven

Compare at least three quotes with the same coverage limits.
Ask which carriers they represent.
Ask how claims are handled and who you call when something happens.

Check the license: New York Department of Financial Services.

Common questions

How many insurance agents are listed in Brookhaven, New York?

USA Business Search shows 31 insurance agents in Brookhaven. 31 list a phone number and 29 list a website.

Which ZIP codes do these listings cover?

They include ZIP codes 11763, 11778, 11772, 11967, 11776, 11779, 11733, 11764.

How do I choose an insurance agency in Brookhaven?

Compare at least three quotes with the same coverage limits. Ask which carriers they represent. Check the license with the New York Department of Financial Services.

How do insurance agents in Brookhaven compare with the rest of New York?

Brookhaven has 0% of the 8,471 insurance agents listed in New York, which ranks #50 among New York cities for this category.

How do I add or fix a listing?

Listings are free. Use Add your business, or the Claim or fix link on any listing.

More finance & insurance in Brookhaven

Financial advisors in Brookhaven Banks & credit unions in Brookhaven Mortgage lenders in Brookhaven

Insurance agents nearby

Insurance agents in Farmingville Insurance agents in Coram Insurance agents in Medford Insurance agents in Selden Insurance agents in Holtsville Insurance agents in Centereach

All insurance agents in New York Insurance agents nationwide

Own one of these businesses? Claim your free listing or see what an optimized listing adds.