Insurance agents in Oyster Bay, NY

22 insurance agents listed in Oyster Bay, New York. 21 with a phone number and 21 with a website.

Oyster Bay accounts for 0% of the insurance agents listed in New York and ranks #79 among New York cities for insurance agents.

Quick answer

Oyster Bay, NY has 22 insurance agents listed on USA Business Search. 21 list a phone number and 21 list a website. The most listings are in ZIP codes 11771, 11758, 11797.

Updated October 2026

Weissman Agency: Allstate Insurance

125 Michael Dr Ste 102, Oyster Bay, NY 11791 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 338-5700 Website Map

The Zabbia Insurance Agency

744 N Broadway, Oyster Bay, NY 11758 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 799-3800 Website Map

SterlingRisk

135 Crossways Park Dr #300, Oyster Bay, NY 11797 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 487-0300 Website Map

Richard Giegerich - Allstate

60 Glen Head Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11545 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 466-2111 Website Map

Anthony Bellomo

67 W Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 · Claim or fix

Call (718) 281-4566 Website Map

Insurance Plus

15 W Main St A, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 922-1200 Website Map

Anthony Sposito - State Farm Insurance Agent

4250 Hempstead Tpke Ste 23, Oyster Bay, NY 11714 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 796-7900 Website Map

Bill Hannan Insurance Agency

70 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 922-1060 Website Map

Brooks Robb & Callahan

35 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 922-6500 Website Map

Crs Insurance Inc

260 N Broadway #9, Oyster Bay, NY 11801 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 733-6700 Website Map

FNA Insurance Services

1000 Woodbury Rd #403, Oyster Bay, NY 11797 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 352-7000 Website Map

Global Planning Advisory

350 Jericho Tpke #312, Oyster Bay, NY 11753 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 829-9100 Website Map

Highland Title Insurance

366 N Broadway ph-e2, Oyster Bay, NY 11753 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 932-6900 Website Map

Insure LI Agency Inc

582 Hicksville Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11758 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 308-4166 Website Map

Janet Maiorello

27 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 466-4200 Map

Matthew Edward Andrews - 123 South St

123 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 · Claim or fix

Website Map

Program Brokerage Corporation

100 Sunnyside Blvd Ext Suite A, Oyster Bay, NY 11797 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 364-7740 Website Map

Steven C Mccarty Agency | Insurance Broker

35 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 326-3580 Website Map

Thomas McCann Insurance

216 N Iowa Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11758 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 695-7188 Website Map

Trident Coverage Insurance

6800 Jericho Tpke Suite 120 W, Oyster Bay, NY 11791 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 820-0277 Website Map

Triple Crown Insurance Brokerage, Inc.

35 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 933-8080 Website Map

William S Jacobs Associates Inc

115 South St Ste 2s, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 · Claim or fix

Call (516) 624-0200 Website Map

How to choose an insurance agency in Oyster Bay

Compare at least three quotes with the same coverage limits.
Ask which carriers they represent.
Ask how claims are handled and who you call when something happens.

Check the license: New York Department of Financial Services.

Common questions

How many insurance agents are listed in Oyster Bay, New York?

USA Business Search shows 22 insurance agents in Oyster Bay. 21 list a phone number and 21 list a website.

Which ZIP codes do these listings cover?

They include ZIP codes 11771, 11758, 11797, 11791, 11753, 11545, 11714, 11801.

How do I choose an insurance agency in Oyster Bay?

Compare at least three quotes with the same coverage limits. Ask which carriers they represent. Check the license with the New York Department of Financial Services.

How do insurance agents in Oyster Bay compare with the rest of New York?

Oyster Bay has 0% of the 8,471 insurance agents listed in New York, which ranks #79 among New York cities for this category.

How do I add or fix a listing?

Listings are free. Use Add your business, or the Claim or fix link on any listing.

More finance & insurance in Oyster Bay

Financial advisors in Oyster Bay Banks & credit unions in Oyster Bay Mortgage lenders in Oyster Bay

Insurance agents nearby

Insurance agents in Jericho Insurance agents in Hicksville Insurance agents in Syosset Insurance agents in Plainview Insurance agents in Woodbury Insurance agents in Old Bethpage

All insurance agents in New York Insurance agents nationwide

Own one of these businesses? Claim your free listing or see what an optimized listing adds.