Thrift & consignment in New York
2,786 thrift & consignment listed across 719 cities in New York.
Thrift & consignment make up 0.4% of New York listings, compared with 0.5% across all states we cover. That ranks New York #5 of 5 states for this category.
Sponsored
Quick answer
USA Business Search lists 2,786 thrift & consignment in New York. The most are in Manhattan (462), Brooklyn (133), Rochester (61).
Updated October 2026Thrift & consignment by city
Manhattan (462)Brooklyn (133)Rochester (61)Buffalo (50)Hudson (46)Bronx (46)Syracuse (26)Albany (21)Huntington (19)Staten Island (18)Binghamton (17)Long Island City (16)Ballston Spa (16)Poughkeepsie (15)Kingston (14)Watertown (13)Plattsburgh (13)Jamaica (13)Corning (13)Clarence (13)Jamestown (12)Auburn (12)Tonawanda (11)Southampton (11)Newburgh (11)Ithaca (11)Hyde Park (11)Saugerties (10)Patchogue (10)Oneonta (10)Niagara Falls (10)Locust Valley (10)Islip (10)Yonkers (9)Rome (9)Red Hook (9)Oyster Bay (9)Oneida (9)New Rochelle (9)Lockport (9)Great Neck (9)Canandaigua (9)Warwick (8)Wappingers Falls (8)Queensbury (8)Port Jervis (8)Oswego (8)Olean (8)Middletown (8)Hoosick Falls (8)Hempstead (8)Glens Falls (8)Freeport (8)Fairport (8)Endicott (8)East Aurora (8)Bouckville (8)Babylon (8)Williamsville (7)White Plains (7)Utica (7)Troy (7)Tarrytown (7)Schenectady (7)Saratoga Springs (7)Rhinebeck (7)Pleasant Valley (7)Owego (7)Ontario (7)Millerton (7)Flushing (7)Farmingdale (7)Cortland (7)Cold Spring (7)Westfield (6)West Seneca (6)Webster (6)Spring Valley (6)Skaneateles (6)North Tonawanda (6)New Windsor (6)Millbrook (6)Marcellus (6)Lindenhurst (6)Huntington Station (6)Hamburg (6)Gloversville (6)Fayetteville (6)East Hampton (6)Dunkirk (6)Delhi (6)Cambridge (6)Caledonia (6)Brockport (6)Bainbridge (6)Amherst (6)Albion (6)Vestal (5)Stanfordville (5)Ravena (5)New Paltz (5)New Hartford (5)Mt Morris (5)Massena (5)Madison (5)Lancaster (5)Hornell (5)Halfmoon (5)Greece (5)Geneva (5)Fulton (5)Fredonia (5)Depew (5)Clifton Park (5)Chester (5)Catskill (5)Baldwinsville (5)Whitehall (4)West Chazy (4)Vernon (4)Valley Stream (4)Trumansburg (4)Syosset (4)Springville (4)Spencerport (4)Southold (4)Sea Cliff (4)Sanborn (4)Sag Harbor (4)Port Washington (4)Penn Yan (4)Pawling (4)Palmyra (4)Ozone Park (4)Nyack (4)North Syracuse (4)Newstead (4)Newark (4)Montgomery (4)Merrick (4)Medina (4)Mamaroneck (4)Liverpool (4)Levittown (4)Larchmont (4)Johnson City (4)Jackson Heights (4)Hunter (4)Hammondsport (4)Greenport (4)Glenville (4)Glendale (4)Glen Cove (4)Eastport (4)Earlville (4)Cazenovia (4)Candor (4)Burnt Hills (4)Brookhaven (4)Bloomfield (4)Bay Shore (4)Bath (4)Astoria (4)Angelica (4)Andes (4)Westmoreland (3)Weedsport (3)Waverly (3)Warsaw (3)Wallkill (3)Victor (3)Valatie (3)Unadilla (3)Tupper Lake (3)Tannersville (3)Suffern (3)South Glens Falls (3)Shokan (3)Shirley (3)Sherburne (3)Selkirk (3)Schoharie (3)Scarsdale (3)Sayville (3)Saranac Lake (3)Ronkonkoma (3)Riverhead (3)Ridgewood (3)Queens Village (3)Pound Ridge (3)Penfield (3)Pearl River (3)Ossining (3)Oceanside (3)Oakdale (3)Norwich (3)Northport (3)North Hempstead (3)New Hyde Park (3)Nanuet (3)Mt Vernon (3)Mt Kisco (3)Mount Kisco (3)Massapequa (3)Macedon (3)Little Falls (3)Liberty (3)Lewiston (3)Le Roy (3)Lawrence (3)Lake Placid (3)Lake Grove (3)Lake George (3)Johnstown (3)Holbrook (3)Hillsdale (3)Hancock (3)Greenwich (3)Granville (3)Goshen (3)Geneseo (3)Garden City (3)Fort Plain (3)Florida (3)Fishkill (3)Elmira (3)Elmhurst (3)Ellenville (3)East Syracuse (3)East Rockaway (3)East Rochester (3)East Northport (3)East Amherst (3)Delmar (3)Cuba (3)Corfu (3)Colonie (3)Cohoes (3)Charlton (3)Chappaqua (3)Canajoharie (3)Broadalbin (3)Brewerton (3)Bellport (3)Beacon (3)Baldwin (3)Avon (3)Arcade (3)Amsterdam (3)Woodhaven (2)Windsor (2)Westhampton Beach (2)Westhampton (2)West Sand Lake (2)West Babylon (2)Watkins Glen (2)Watervliet (2)Waterloo (2)Walton (2)Walden (2)Wading River (2)Tuxedo Park (2)Ticonderoga (2)Sylvan Beach (2)Stone Ridge (2)Stanley (2)Stamford (2)St. James (2)Springwater (2)Springfield (2)Solvay (2)Sodus (2)Sloatsburg (2)Sidney (2)Seneca Falls (2)Salamanca (2)Sackets Harbor (2)Rye (2)Rouses Point (2)Roslyn (2)Rosedale (2)Roscoe (2)Rockville Centre (2)Richmondville (2)Richmond Hill (2)Remsen (2)Rego Park (2)Pulaski (2)Potsdam (2)Pittsford (2)Peekskill (2)Patterson (2)Otsego (2)Old Forge (2)Olcott (2)Oak Hill (2)Newfield (2)Nassau (2)Munnsville (2)Mount Vernon (2)Mount Morris (2)Moriches (2)Moravia (2)Monticello (2)Mongaup Valley (2)Mohawk (2)Minoa (2)Mineola (2)Milford (2)Melrose (2)Medford (2)Mechanicville (2)Mattituck (2)Margaretville (2)Marathon (2)Manhasset (2)Malverne (2)Malone (2)Mahopac (2)Madrid (2)Lyons (2)Lowville (2)Livonia (2)Lima (2)Leicester (2)Lansing (2)Lackawanna (2)Katonah (2)Johnsburg (2)Jasper (2)Island Park (2)Inwood (2)Ilion (2)Hudson Falls (2)Honeoye Falls (2)Holland Patent (2)Hobart (2)Hicksville (2)Herkimer (2)Hampton Bays (2)Hamilton (2)Groton (2)Greenville (2)Gardiner (2)Franklin (2)Frankfort (2)Fort Edward (2)Forest Hills (2)Floral Park (2)Evans Mills (2)Elmsford (2)Elmont (2)Elma (2)East Bloomfield (2)Dundee (2)Duanesburg (2)Deposit (2)De Witt (2)De Kalb Junction (2)Croton-On-Hudson (2)Coxsackie (2)Copiague (2)Cooperstown (2)Commack (2)Cold Spring Harbor (2)Cochecton (2)Cobleskill (2)Clifton Springs (2)Clarence Center (2)Churchville (2)Cheektowaga (2)Chaumont (2)Central Islip (2)Centereach (2)Cedarhurst (2)Cattaraugus (2)Carroll (2)Carmel Hamlet (2)Canton (2)Canastota (2)Canaseraga (2)Callicoon (2)Bridgehampton (2)Boonville (2)Bolton Landing (2)Bohemia (2)Big Flats (2)Bellmore (2)Bellerose (2)Bedford Hills (2)Batavia (2)Barneveld (2)Ballston Lake (2)Baldwin Place (2)Aurora (2)Armonk (2)Akron (2)Afton (2)Youngsville (1)Yorkville (1)
Showing the 400 cities with the most thrift & consignment. Use search to find any other town.
Well-documented thrift & consignment in New York
A sample of listings with a street address, phone number and website, one per city.
Goodwill of the Finger Lakes
Thrifty Shopper
Kid to Kid Rochester
Thrifty Shopper
Pawn Express
Savers
Goodwill Store and Donation Center
Once Upon A Child
Kid to Kid West Seneca
Goodwill NYNJ
Roycroft Campus Antiques
How to choose a thrift store in New York
- Check hours and stock by phone before you make the trip.
- Ask about return and exchange policies.
- Ask whether they price-match or offer local delivery.
Common questions
How many thrift & consignment are listed in New York?
USA Business Search lists 2,786 thrift & consignment across 719 New York cities and towns.
Which New York cities have the most thrift & consignment?
Manhattan (462), Brooklyn (133), Rochester (61), Buffalo (50), Hudson (46).
How do I choose a thrift store in New York?
Check hours and stock by phone before you make the trip. Ask about return and exchange policies.
How do I add or fix a listing?
Listings are free. Use Add your business, or the Claim or fix link on any listing.